Throughout this weeks readings, there have been many intense themes such as individuality, faith, loneliness, etc. One theme that really stood out to me during the reading was freedom. Freedom through the readings is not talked about as in our amendments such as freedom of speech, or the right to bear arms, but instead it is being talked about more as your independence as an individual. Through the years the question of “is freedom really free” has became more and more popular. After reading the piece that really focused on freedom, and Dr.Absher’s blog, it really got me thinking on why people question is freedom is really free. We as people have free will, we have the right to make our own decisions no matter what they are. A very good example that explains freedom is in the book when the narrator explains how his liver is diseased, and that he refuses to fix it. He continues to explain that he is refusing to get medical treatment “out of spite”. The narrator specifically states:
“My liver is bad, well – then let it get even worse”
Now you might question why one would even say this, or come to this point? The narrator is showing that he has the freedom to make the choice that he wants to make, regardless of his injury or disease. The question still arises that if we are able to have our own sense of free will, then why do we question if freedom is really free? In Dr.Absher’s blog, there is a clear explanation about how freedom must be demonstrated through rebellion. Maybe this could be some insight to our answer. We believe that freedom is not really free because we choose to rebel against everything that we can. Going back to the example with the narrator refusing medical treatment for his liver disease, you can see clearly that he is rebelling just to have a choice that he wants to make. He is going against the advice that the medical professionals would give him to treat his liver disease to fulfill his free-will and the freedom that he has in refusing medical treatment.
Going further in the discussion of freedom, it is only right that we talk about what is known as the “most advantageous advantage”. The most advantageous advantage actually helps us explain why we would show rebellion, just to prove our freedom. The narrator states that:
“…And what if it so happens that a man’s advantage sometimes not only may, but even must, consist exactly in his desiring under certain conditions what is harmful to himself and not what is advantageous.”
This is saying that we will harm ourselves just so we feel free. We will push away our only happiness, we will harm our on physical bodies, we will drive the people who are having a positive impact on the society away just because we want to prove we have freedom. Sometimes having to prove that we have freedom or a free will harms us more than does us any good. The answer on whether or not freedom is really free can be so back and forth, it is really how you look at the situation and your opinion. Sure we have the right to speak up, and give us a sense of freedom, but on the other hand, we also harm ourselves just to feel a sense a freedom or free will. So the question is up to you, do you believe that freedom is really free?
I found this really interesting Ted Talks video about freedom on youtube. If you would like to watch it, click here.
I hope you enjoyed my post! Comments are always appreciated!
